Patek Philippe 5711 vs 5167 — Which Steel Sports Patek Holds Its Value Better?
Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 vs Aquanaut 5167: Value, Wearability, and Which to Buy
The 5711: The Discontinued Icon
The Nautilus 5711 was produced from 2006 until 2021, spanning no fewer than 18 references including the Tiffany-signed blue dial and the farewell olive-green 5711/1A-014 – . Its discontinuation was arguably the single most significant event in modern steel sports watch collecting. In 2015, a 5711/1A-010 blue dial traded for around $25,000. By early 2024, that same reference had crossed $134,000, and the green-dial 014 has since reached $315,000.
The watch itself is 40mm in stainless steel, just 8.3mm thick, with an integrated bracelet and the horizontally embossed dial that defines the Nautilus family. The Caliber 26-330 S C is an automatic with date and seconds — the exact daily-wear configuration that made the 5711 a one-watch answer for buyers who wanted sport and formality in the same package.
Current secondary pricing for the blue-dial 5711/1A-010 clusters between $80,000 and $130,000 depending on condition and provenance, with full-set examples at the upper end of that range – . cheap watches for men online
The 5167A: The Value Play
The Aquanaut 5167A-001 is a 40.8mm stainless steel watch with a rounded octagonal bezel, a black embossed relief dial, and a composite rubber strap. It launched in 1997 as a younger, more relaxed alternative to the Nautilus, and for most of its life it was exactly that — the more affordable, less hyped sibling.
That changed. As the 5711 became unattainable and then discontinued, attention shifted to the 5167A. Retail was around $27,000 at current Patek pricing, and the secondary market has stabilised in the $70,000–$80,000 range for full-set examples — a premium, but a far less violent one than the 5711’s – .
What makes the 5167A interesting is that it never claimed to be an investment piece. It is a comfortable, lightweight, genuinely wearable daily watch — many long-term owners describe it as the most comfortable watch in their collection, with the caveat that the steel bezel is soft and picks up scratches easily.
The Value Question
If you are buying for value retention, the 5711 has the stronger historical case: it is discontinued, it is iconic, and its floor has held above $80,000 even after the post-2022 correction. But the entry price is also five times higher. wholesale replica watches
If you are buying to wear, the 5167A is the more honest answer. It is a better daily watch than the 5711 in almost every practical sense — lighter, more comfortable on rubber, and less precious about being worn. It has also demonstrated that it can hold value without relying on the same level of hype.
For a collector who wants one steel sports Patek and actually intends to wear it, the 5167A makes more sense. For a collector who wants the reference that defined an era — and is prepared to treat it as a safe queen — the 5711 is the one. https://www.chrono-wrist.co.uk/